States have been given the leeway to tweak the criteria for division of taxpayers after “consultation with Centre” in respect of cross empowerment under the proposed Goods and Services Tax (GST).
The minutes of the ninth meeting of the GST Council, held on January 16, record that the states have been given this concession over and above the agreed upon 90:10 division of tax assessees below the annual turnover threshold of Rs 1.5 crore between states and Centre, respectively, and an equal division of assessees for a turnover above Rs 1.5 crore.
“those states wanting a different basis of division could do so in consultation with the Centre; the division of taxpayers in each state shall be done by computer at the state level based in stratified random sampling and could also take into account the geographical location and type of the taxpayers, as may be mutually agreed,” the minutes stated.
The division of taxpayers will be switched between the Centre and the states at regular intervals as per the decision of the Council. For new registrants, the Council has agreed to do equal division between the Centre and the states.
During the course of the discussions, states such as West Bengal and Kerala supported the demand for exclusive control by states on taxpayers below the Rs 1.5 crore turnover threshold, while Gujarat and Maharashtra stated their preference for vertical division with control of two-third taxpayers with states and one-third of the assessees with the Centre.
CBEC chairman Najib Shah was of the view that neither the Central nor state tax administration should be completely ousted from any part of the value chain in order to ensure proper checks and balances. During the discussions, he also stated that there could be cross empowerment for granting tax refund subject to agreement by the accounting authorities.
For the process of refund, the states and the Centre did not converge on cross empowerment as there were legal issues relating to Consolidated Fund of India being operated by a state government official and a central government official and the corresponding modalities of audit of such refunds. Also, after consultation with the law ministry, the GST Council agreed for cross empowerment of powers under the Integrated GST (IGST) Act in line with Central GST (CGST) and State GST (SGST) Acts, with the exception that the Centre alone will have the power to adjudicate a case where the disputed issue relates to place of supply, or issue relating to import/export of goods and services, or when an affected state requests that the case be adjudicated by the CGST authority.
The arrangement between the Centre and the states in the ninth GST Council meeting to break the deadlock on division of control has been seen as a compromise on part of the Centre, as it has lost out on the maximum share of taxpayers under the threshold of Rs 1.5 crore.
Currently, 93 per cent of service tax assessees and 85 per cent of the VAT taxpayers have a turnover below Rs 1.5 crore. Under the proposed GST, taxpayers having a turnover of over Rs 1.5 crore are estimated to contribute almost 90 per cent of the revenue.
The fine print pertaining to the division will be discussed in the tenth GST Council meeting on Saturday, wherein states and Centre will finalise the legally vetted draft GST bills, following which the Centre is likely to introduce them in the second half of the Budget session of the Parliament. The government intends to rollout the indirect tax regime from July 1 this year. The government is constitutionally mandated as per the Constitution (One Hundred and First Amendment) Act, 2016, passed by Parliament last year, to roll out the indirect tax regime by September 16 this year.